Windstream vs. Xfinity: Which Internet Provider is Better?
Asenqua Tech is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Xfinity is the largest ISP in the US while Windstream claims to be the biggest 8-gig internet provider in the nation. If both are available where you live, one is categorically better than the other depending on the local network architecture.
Windstream Internet is provided via a fiber connection in many of its service areas, which is faster and more reliable than Xfinity’s cable service. However, where Windstream only offers DSL internet, Xfinity may be the better option. Here are some of the key differences between Xfinity and Windstream:
| Windstream | Xfinity |
| Windstream offers unlimited data with all internet plans | Xfinity Internet has a 1.2 TB data cap in most service areas |
| Windstream internet plans are free from term contracts. | Some Xfinity offers may require a term contract. |
| Windstream offers symmetrical speeds with fiber internet. | Xfinity currently only offers asymmetrical plans. |
Let’s compare Windstream and Xfinity in terms of different factors to see which is better.
Windstream vs. Xfinity: Head-to-Head Comparison
Technology
Windstream uses fiber technology in some areas and DSL in others. Fiber affords the fastest internet speeds available today with a degree of reliability and consistency that other technologies can’t match. DSL only supports speeds up to 100 Mbps.
On the other hand, Xfinity mainly provides cable Internet. Cable Internet trots along with coaxial cables that were originally designed for television service. These cables can deliver high-speed internet, but they’re like the trusty old steed compared to the sleek, futuristic rocket ship of fiber optics.
So, in terms of technology alone, Windstream fiber is superior to Xfinity cable, which is better than Windstream DSL. You can reach out to Windstream customer service to learn which type of internet is available in your area.
Speeds
Hold onto your socks because fiber-optic connections are here to blow them off! Windstream offers symmetrical speeds (upload and download) ranging from 500 Mbps to 8 Gbps, making it one of the fastest ISPs in the US.
Xfinity only offers speeds ranging from 100 Mbps to 2 Gbps in most areas. Because Xfinity uses cable, internet speeds are not symmetrical. However, Xfinity plans to bring symmetrical speeds to cable with DOCSIS 4.0 technology soon.
Reliability
Think of fiber-optic connections as the solid, unwavering lighthouse in the digital storm. Windstream Internet is as dependable as a trusty sidekick, impervious to the whims of the weather, and less susceptible to slowdowns during peak usage hours.
Xfinity Internet is more like a crowded freeway during rush hour—sometimes you breeze through, and sometimes you’re stuck in a traffic jam. Network congestion can lead to slowdowns during prime time. Still, Xfinity is one of the more reliable cable internet providers with a Consistency Score of 91.5% according to Ookla’s Market Analysis.
Latency
When it comes to latency, fiber-optic connections are the Olympic sprinters of the internet world. Windstream fiber internet has a clear edge in terms of low latency, making it perfect for online gaming and video conferences.
Xfinity Internet, while no slouch, has slightly higher latency due to its technology and infrastructure. It measures a median multi-server latency of 25 ms on Ookla’s Market Analysis.
Cost
Xfinity’s basic internet plan (100 Mbps) starts at a promotional price of $30 per month for 12 months, whereas Windstream’s starter fiber plan (500 Mbps) costs $39.99. However, Windstream’s gig plan costs $69.99 for 12 months whereas Xfinity charges $75 per month for years with a 2-year term contract for the same speed. So, Xfinity Internet starts cheaper but Windstream gives more bang for the buck.
Now that you’re curious about pricing, let’s look at the plans offered by each internet provider.
Windstream Internet Plans
Kinetic Internet Basic (DSL)
Priced at an enticing $39.99 per month for the initial 12 months, this plan bursts onto the scene with a respectable 100 Mbps, ideal for your everyday internet needs. This option is not as fast as fiber or cable internet. We’d recommend going with Xfinity Internet instead if it’s available.
Kinetic Fiber Internet
For the savvy user craving more oomph, Windstream presents the Kinetic Fiber Internet at the same tempting $39.99 per month for the first year. This plan boasts a whopping 500 Mbps of lightning-fast internet speeds, perfect for those who crave HD streaming and seamless multitasking.
Kinetic Fiber Internet GIG
Step into the realm of digital extravagance with the Kinetic Fiber Internet GIG, priced at $69.99 per month for the inaugural 12 months. Elevating your online experience with a colossal 1000 Mbps, this plan unlocks the world of 4K video streaming, smooth online gaming, and rapid file downloads.
Kinetic Fiber Internet 2 GIG
The Kinetic Fiber Internet 2 GIG plan propels you into the stratosphere of internet speeds with a staggering 2000 Mbps. Perfectly suited for tech connoisseurs, gamers, and households with insatiable bandwidth appetites, though, pricing for this speed demon does vary by location.
Kinetic Fiber Internet 8 GIG
For those who demand nothing but the absolute best, Windstream introduces the Kinetic Fiber Internet 8 GIG. Surpassing all expectations with an awe-inspiring 8000 Mbps, this plan caters to the elite of the internet world. Much like the 2 GIG plan, pricing for this premium experience is tailored to your specific location
Xfinity Internet Plans
Connect
Xfinity’s starter internet plan costs $30 per month for 12 months a 75 Mbps max download speed and a 10 Mbps max upload speed. The best part? No pesky long-term contract required! It’s perfect for those who demand freedom and affordability in their internet experience.
Connect More
Behold the Connect More plan, a mere $25 a month for a 200 Mbps download speed and a steady 10 Mbps upload speed. Say goodbye to tangled cables because WiFi equipment is included! No need to commit long-term either, making it a sweet deal for your online needs.
Fast
Fast is the name, and fast is the game with this plan! For just $50 a month over 24 months, you’ll enjoy a scorching 400 Mbps download speed. While the upload speed stays at 10 Mbps, it’s ideal for households filled with tech enthusiasts and multiple devices. And the best part? No tiresome contracts to worry about.
Superfast
For those who crave speed, Superfast delivers an 800 Mbps max download speed and a 20 Mbps max upload speed. However, this plan requires a 2-year term contract commitment. If you’re willing to commit, this plan promises a lightning-fast internet journey.
Gigabit
Gigabit is the heavyweight champion, offering a mind-boggling 1000 Mbps download speed and a solid 20 Mbps upload speed. It’s the ultimate choice for data-hungry users and larger households. Just keep in mind that you’re locked into a 2-year term contract. But hey, the price is right for such supercharged speeds!
Gigabit Extra
Gigabit Extra cranks it up to 11 with an astounding 1200 Mbps download speed and a zippy 35 Mbps upload speed. It’s the apex of internet speed! The only catch? You guessed it, a 2-year term contract. But for those who demand the best, it’s worth every penny for this lightning-fast experience.
Conclusion
Windstream has the advantage of symmetrical speeds, unlimited data, and contract-free plans over Xfinity, however, it only offers DSL internet in most areas. Choose Windstream Internet if it’s available via fiber in your area but go with Xfinity otherwise.
